Monday, January 20, 2014

Isaac Latterell Ignores the Real Issues Facing District 6 and South Dakota

We all know that Isaac Latterell chooses to ignore the evidence that getting and keeping teachers in South Dakota is a serious problem.  It seems that his main driving force for serving District 6 is to take on the federal government.  

Mr. Latterell posts on his website about what he took from the State of the State address from Governor Daugaard.  To summarize he concludes that the economy is great, but we need to watch out what the Federal Reserve and the Federal Government is doing.

But there is another constraint that reality places on South Dakota, and rightly so: we can’t print money. Or to put it another way, diluting money–your money. Even the word used to describe the result (“inflation”) is deceptive, because it implies that the products and services are becoming more valuable, when in fact it’s your paycheck and your savings becoming less valuable. 
The primary beneficiaries of inflation are the Federal Reserve Banks. The Fed is a non-governmental organization of banks authorized by congress with no audit level oversight by anyone, including congress. That’s why inflation is referred to as the “hidden tax” which actually hurts the poor and lower income the most, and keeps them from achieving economic security. That’s why I co-sponsored a resolution this year calling for an audit of the Fed....
He continues about the evils of the Federal Reserve and leads into joining the Convention of States because that is what everyone in District 6 is worried about.

While I may not agree with Ernie Otten and Herman Otten on much in politics, at least they try to focus on some issues directly impacting the citizens that voted them to office.  Maybe Mr. Latterell should focus on trying to help Tea High School with more funding and ways to get out of stick buildings...
More space is badly needed, district officials said, because enrollment has steadily climbed and buildings are reaching capacity. Several “stick buildings,” which don’t have running water, are being used to manage growing class sizes. 
Maybe pushing for a resolution to get the needed funding for the Lewis and Clark water system.  How about better funding for our districts to help them with increasing costs of road construction, infrastructure development, and to fight crime.  I won't go into the working poor in his district that would benefit from expansion of Medicaid or all the people in our district connected with medical services and schools that would benefit from an increase in funding for education or healthcare.  

I hope Mr. Latterell can figure what really matters to District 6 and focus on that and not Tea Party issues.

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Isaac Latterell Must Think He Is a Teacher, But That Will Not Deal With the Teacher Shortage

Isaac Latterell, Representative of District 6, was one of 18 house Representatives to vote against a resolution that recognizes the teacher shortage that is hitting South Dakota.  Cory Heidelberger does a nice job of going into details about the vote.  Mr. Latterell chooses to vote with BFF Jenna Haggar instead of listening to the facts of a bi-partisan panel that investigated the problem.  

The reason he might not think there is a shortage is that he feels he is an accomplished "teacher" of government.  Back in October Mr. Latterell with Jenna Haggar shares this video about the basic structure of the republic form of government.  

(I WOULD POST THE VIDEO, BUT A 49 MINUTE VIDEO IS A LITTLE TO MUCH FOR ANYONE AND I AM HAVING TROUBLE WITH VIMEO)

Here are a few friendly teacher tips:

1. Don't lecture for 49 minutes.  You should have a variety of activities to help keep the class engaged.

2. Teaching is about encouraging students to develop his or her own thoughts, not to make political statements.  

3. Avoid words like "peons" (around 9 minutes in).  This just makes the students giggle.

4. Avoid comparing other forms of government to slavery.  (9:30 minutes in) You may like drawing chains, but it is a poor analogy that may offend members in your school district and students you are teaching.

5. I wouldn't take stands on the government shut down.  (20 minutes in) Your statement and the way you just shrug it off might be a problem for a student whose mom or dad work with EROS datacenter, a FDA inspector, a member of the National Guard in Sioux Falls, or a rancher that could not get assistance after a horrible, horrible blizzard.

6. By the way, Tim Johnson is also a Senator from South Dakota.  You just mention John Thune.

7. Never a good idea to start lecturing about the teachings of the God or the Bible when teaching a government class in a public school setting.  You may offend the atheist in the class room, the Buddhists, the practitioners of Hinduism, (you get the point).  You are also violating the concept of Separation of church and state.  

I could go on, but hopefully you will take this opportunity to reflect about how you did using the Danielson model and redevelop a new lesson plan explaining how you are meeting the state standards and teaching to all of your student learning styles.  I also expect that you will get this done while attending multiple committee meetings, coaching an activity, staying around to help a student improve from the last unit or make up work missed while on vacation, and working another job to help make your family bills.


Still Missing the Big Issue

As expected Common Core is becoming one of the big issues this year in Pierre with three bills related to the Common Core already in the mix.  The first Senate bill, SB 62, seems to be one that is coming a little late and is repetitive of a process that was already followed.  The main focus of the bill is to establish a committee in Pierre made up of politicians, educators, and parents to study the impact of the Common Core and the Smarter Balanced testing will have on our state.  This bill seems to represent the idea that there had not been any public meetings on the previous standards or the overall implementation of the common core standards in our fair state; however that is not the case:
South Dakota is one step closer to adopting the Common Core State Standards. At its Sept. 28 meeting, the state Board of Education voted to move the Common Core to a public hearing in November.
In fact the DOE has put out a simple power point to clear up some of the misconceptions being dealt with this and other bills with the common core.  In the end I view this bill as harmless and more public hearings on the issue before adopting new standards and hearings about the Smarter Balanced test are never a bad thing.

Then comes along SB 64.  This one is more of a head scratcher.  I get the purpose, to try and slow down implementation of the Common Core, but it would have no impact on the current standards over math and English that have already been adopted.
 Prior to July 1, 2016, the Board of Education may not, pursuant to § 13-3-48, adopt any uniform content standards drafted by a multistate consortium which are intended for adoption in two or more states. However, this section does not apply to content standards whose adoption by the Board of Education was completed and finalized prior to July 1, 2014. 
 Plus adds the word "implemented" after adopted.  So the idea is that the standards might be adopted but not implemented.  More meetings are not a bad thing overall, but this also misses the mark I am going to talk about a little later.

The third is SB 63, or as I like to call it: The Tin Foil Hat Bill.  This bill has several problems with it and tries to stop things that are not happening to my or anyone else's knowledge.  Pat Powers at SD War College points out some of the problems with this bill.

So, how on earth do the sponsors of the measure expect schools to evaluate children for things like autism, dyslexia, ADHD, or a tremendous host of any other of dozens of learning disorders, if they are prevented from “analyzing or evaluating” students? 
And those more serious mental disorders, such as schizophrenia? A lot of times those are noticed & identified by school personnel. 
Unless the legislature is going to direct schools to fire all of their school psychologists, this measure has parts that need some serious reworking.
I wonder if the government teacher will be able to talk about the different political parties and have them do an project that identifies where they may fall on the political spectrum.  I also don't know of any schools surveying students on if they or their parents own a gun.  This kind of bill hurts the chances of real educational reform, because it is too easy to dismiss those "silly" bills.

The biggest problem is that all three of the bills miss the mark.  While they are willing to come after the education department, they fail to find a way to help teachers become better.  They fail to provide anything that will give teachers tools to become better instructors.  Things like focusing on any test results as a judge of schools or teachers do not make our schools better.  Even though Secretary Melody Schoop is willing to fight for the testing,
Testing also will show how students compare with those in other states, Schopp said. The first online tests under Common Core will be given this spring but will be used mainly to determine how the test works and whether districts have sufficient Internet capacity and equipment, she said.
It is never been clear how this will have any effective information that your classroom teacher will be able to use.   It is things like HB 1005 and HB 1002 that look for ways other than testing to improve education.  Push for more meetings with Common Core, but how will that encourage more of our young, talented South Dakotans to enter the teaching profession?  How will is build teacher moral and keep our experienced teachers in the state?  How will it give teachers the tools needed to continue to provide quality education in our state?  That should be the biggest focus in Pierre when it comes helping education.

Monday, January 6, 2014

Evidence of the Governor's Short-Sighted Focus on Businesses Over Education

It is legislative season and it seems that the only thing colder than the weather is Governor Daugaard's feelings toward education.  We know that the Governor loves to talk a good game during election year when it comes to education, but unless he has a serious opponent, you can't expect Daugaard to support education.  No one should believe him when he claims that he is a supporter of our children's education.

South Dakota legislators will need to decide what to do with a huge windfall of funds.  The governor wants to pre-pay $30 million of the unclaimed funds into Building South Dakota.

Now Gov. Daugaard is suggesting legislators consider a new arrangement in the 2014 legislative session. He wants to use $30 million from the unexpectedly large pot of money to “pre-pay” three years of Building South Dakota, or BSD. 
The $30 million is significantly less than the BSD fund would receive otherwise under the law passed last year: Approximately $30 million this year and approximately $35 million each year thereafter. 
Right now there isn’t sufficient demand to use all of that money for economic development and related programs under the BSD umbrella. If legislators accept the deal, the big unknown is what happens when the governor’s $30 million “pre-pay” is gone.
This has many legislatures frustrated and a bit confused as to why the Governor would want to mess with a true bi-partisan law that created the law for Building South Dakota.  Bernie Hunhoff, Democratic Minority Leader in the House, shared his concern on Facebook after Daugaard's announcement:
Some good, some bad in the governor's proposed budget. Finally, an acknowledgment that we need to help schools dig out of the hole caused by 2010 cuts. And paying off debt with one-time dollars to create more ongoing revenue for basic responsibilities like health care and education make sense to me. The bad? I hope we're not already going to mess with the Building South Dakota program that was just agreed to last session. And it's a travesty not to expand Medicaid.
So what seems to be Daugaard's problem with the law?  The fact that it has triggers that would avoid his being able to cut education funding again.
“The Governor's main concern with the funding of BSD last year was that it include a trigger so that funding would be available to fund K-12 at the statutory level, and Medicaid and state salary policy at that same level, before funding BSD. That proposal was included in the final bill,” Venhuizen said. 
It seems that his priorities are set: funding for businesses comes first and funding for education should take a distant back seat.   

One area that the funds could be used is supporting need based aid.  In March South Dakota started funding for need-based aid for students attending post secondary education (last ones to do it in the nation), but those funds were underfunded.  (SURPRISE)
In March, when South Dakota became the last state in the country to offer need-based assistance for postsecondary education, lawmakers appropriated $1.5 million as the principal seed money for the program, and another $200,000 one time to show the effect it would have in this current academic year. 
That $200,000 was predicted to produce 800 to 1,000 scholarships ranging from $500 to $2,000. But unless legislators approve more one-time dollars to get back to that $200,000 level next year, it will have only the interest earned on the market value of the $1.5 million investment to pay for the grants. 
And because the law allows only 4 percent of interest earned to be used for scholarships — any additional interest is to be used to grow the market value of the investment — that means the state probably will see only $60,000 to $75,000 annually in the next few years.
A little bit of investment can really help some students and therefor improve the future of our state.
It also could see higher returns if the Legislature invests more in the principal. Turman expects the South Dakota Student Federation will lobby for such a move this next legislative session. D.J. Smith, executive director of the federation, said the governor hasn't devoted any more for the needs-based scholarship in his preliminary budget. 
Meanwhile, the state required the 18 institutions receiving need-based dollars to match them at a 3-to-1 level. In USD's case, that means it had to provide $86,373 to students based on financial need this school year to get the $28,791. Pier said USD paid that $28,000-plus out almost entirely in $1,000 scholarships. 
 Support for education in South Dakota or making sure big businesses can get more breaks: We know where the Governor stands.

Thursday, January 2, 2014

SD Legislature Catching On?

Bob Mercer had a very somewhat hopeful/ depressing article on December 31 about the plight of teachers.  He reports that HCR 1002 will be introduced in the upcoming legislative session.  This finally recognizes a problem that those of us in the education field have been aware of for quiet some time.
A legislative study committee filed a resolution that concludes “teachers are in short supply in this state, and that school districts of all sizes are now struggling to retain qualified teachers and to fill teacher vacancies.”
He pointed out that it is just not in the field of sciences that this shortage has spread through out many different areas.
The four traditional areas of need – math, science, special education and speech – now also include art, career and technical education, English as a new language, health, music, physical education, social science, language arts and world languages.
That is the depressing part.  It is harder and harder to see where future teachers will come from.  In our debate community, we have noticed this problem for years.  The fear is that when a coach is looking at retiring, there is no one there to replace that coach.  This is especially true in the smaller schools.

The possible good news can be seen in the resolved statements:
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that this Legislature joins school officials in acknowledging that teachers are a highly valued resource in this state, and in exploring tuition reimbursement programs and other programs or policies that could help attract more good people into the teaching profession in South Dakota, and to keep the good teachers that are already here.
I can only hope that something meaningful that shows respect for the teaching field and support for teachers in South Dakota will actually happen and not another Daugaard attempt of trying to bring workers from other places.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Why the Common Cores move from novels is wrong!

One of the biggest concerns that people have with the Common Core is the obsession with non-fiction and teaching students to learn to read instruction manuals.  

Because the actual Common Core exams have not yet been formulated, there is no list of what literature students may or may not be tested on. But critics say the stated policy of emphasizing "informational," or non-fiction reading, in English will inevitably come at the expense of literature classics. Those time-tested books are not simply fun to read, according to Brigham Young University English Prof. Alan Manning, they teach students how to write. 
"An argument can be made that any improvement in reading/writing instruction should include more rather than fewer exercises where students write stories themselves that are modeled on the classics," Manning wrote in an e-mail to Utah activists opposed to Common Core. "This creates a more stable foundation on which students can build skills for other kinds of writing. The Core standards would prevent public schools from testing these kinds of approaches."
It turns out that if you want to expand children and adults' minds, you should read more novels and more fiction!  A recent study was completed examining the impact that reading a fictional novel can have the brain of the readers.  

“The neural changes that we found associated with physical sensation and movement systems suggest that reading a novel can transport you into the body of the protagonist,” Berns said. 
“We already knew that good stories can put you in someone else’s shoes in a figurative sense. Now we’re seeing that something may also be happening biologically.”
I guess we will read this non-fictional study about why we should be reading more fiction in the classroom. 

Monday, December 9, 2013

How Joe Lowe's running has already had a positive impact on South Dakota.

Joe Lowe is running as a Democrat and Daugaard has taken notice.  If Joe Lowe doesn't win, at least just running will be a positive impact for South Dakota, because Daugaard changed his tune on education funding in a matter of a few days.

On December 1, the Argus Leader reported Daugaard saying that he would only offer a 1.6% increase to education.  
The governor said state revenue is just too uncertain to help schools and Medicaid providers as much as he might like. 
“We have some additional ongoing revenue, but not enough, really, to give people a lot more than the (rate of inflation),” Daugaard said. 
Note in the article that Senate Majority Leader Tim Rave talks about the unexpected $70 million windfall of money coming into the state.

Then enter Joe Lowe:
"If the tactics aren't working day one through seven, do you stick with the same tactics? No you don't, you move on. And you move on and change your tactics or get a new team. We've had the old team for a long time and I haven't seen much change in tactics," Lowe said. 
And that includes more transparency in our state government and higher wages for teachers. 
"Teacher pay, teacher pay we're last. What's our future, our future is children, change the world of a child and you change the world," Lowe said.
There was no big announcement in front of TV cameras for Lowe to declare his candidacy, just simply this press release, for now. 
Then a few days later, the Governor's budget increase for education jumped up to 3%.  It makes a person go "Hmmmm."

I am not the only one that noticed the sudden switch.  Representative Tyler comments about the sudden about face:
The Governor is proposing to pay off some bonds and pay cash for the state’s share of the veterans’ home in the Black Hills. He also upped his percentage of increase to education and Medicaid providers from 1.6% to 3.0%. Interesting how that increase happened right after another gubernatorial candidate threw his hat into the ring. And, no, the funding is still not where it would have been if those programs hadn’t been unnecessarily cut in 2011. 
I hope that South Dakota voters won't be fooled again.  Remember that Daugaard was the one running on the idea that education was just fine in South Dakota in 2010, and then offered a 10% cut one year to be followed by education proposals that were soundly defeated by the general populace the next year.  Governor Daugaard is not a friend of education.  He is not supportive of education in this state.  Don't forget our history, because if we do, Daugaard may cut funding for history classes in the next budget.